It’s All in the Details
If you’re looking for more information this is the page for you. Here you will find everything you need to know about tasty flavors, custom products, order pricing, and more.
Cookie Flavors
Plain Jane: She’s simple and sweet, just like this cookie. Classic vanilla and almond flavors come together in just the right combination, making this cookie a sure crowd-pleaser. It’s a little bit sugar cookie, a little bit shortbread, and a whole lot of delicious.
Cocoa Loco: The classic cookie takes a turn into the land of fudgy, creamy, melted chocolate. A rich chocolate dough and bits of chocolate chips make this cookie heaven for chocolate lovers.
The Apple Pie of My Eye: This sugary cinnamon cookie dough is filled with fresh apple pieces sprikled without, giving a new look to your favorite fall dessert. This cookie is so good, it may make you want to give up pie altogether!
Pumpkin Spice and Everything Nice: Nothing says fall quite like pumpkin spice. This delicious pumpkin pie cookie has fresh pumpkin and all of those warm, lovely spices mixed together to create a flavor you know and love.
Maple Delight: This comforting maple cookie is sure to melt in your mouth! With a soft, butterty flavor that’s perfect for cozy fall days.
Don’t Be Salty: Be sweet! Starting with homemade, slow-cooked, brown butter caramel, it’s hard to imagine this cookie getting any better. But it does! Stir in flakes of sea salt and you have sweet and salty perfection.
Mellow Yellow: This bright yellow, lemon cookie is sure to melt in your mouth. A thick and creamy lemon curd is the secret sauce behind the dreamy familiar lemon bar flavor (literally).
Peachy Keen: Homemade peach ice cream becomes cookie-fied in this delectable, seasonal flavor. All the comfort of warm vanilla and fresh peaches come together in a light and fluffy bite of summer.
Not Your Momma’s Matcha: This pale green cookie is a matcha lover’s dream. Bright green tea flavor combines with a hint of white chocolate and almond to create a cookie unlike any other.
Strawberry Fields Forever: “Nothing is real”—except these fresh, local strawberries. Juicy, red, and packed with flavor, perfectly picked strawberries are what give this cookie its bold flavor and pastel color.
Party Animal: Whoever says sprinkles are for kids is lying. The nostalgic flavor and rainbow dots of funfetti cake bake their way into this youthful cookie. If you’re looking for a taste of childhood, this just might be it.
If You Like Piña Coladas…: You’re probably going to love this cookie. The vibrant tang of pineapple is balanced with creamy, toasty coconut creating a flavor that needs to be enjoyed by the beach.
Mango Tango: This orange-colored cookie is simple and exquisite—packed to the brim with fresh mangoes. The summer flavor is so loud and bright, it’ll make you want to get up and dance!
The Bee’s Knees: This lavender honey cookie is full of sweet spring aromas. A sugared honey dough meets the subtle flavor of lavender infused sugar for a delightful seasonal treat.
Cup O’ Joe: Your morning cup just became a cookie. Flavored with pure espresso powder, this coffee flavor is sure to please. Balanced with dark chocolate and steamed milk, you’ll feel like the coffee shop came to you.
Nuts About You: Peanut butter lovers, this one’s for you. Creamy or chunky? The jury’s still out. But they did agree that this cookie is the best of both worlds. A little crunch, a little chew, all with the purest, locally made peanut butter—what more could you ask for?
Poolside (out of season): If it wasn’t summer already, it sure is now! The bright pink color gives this cookie a recognizable look like no other. Poolside is a pop of pink lemonade flavor made with the freshest ingredients. Tart fruits simmer with sweet sugar making this cookie perfect for eating, well…poolside.
Tangerine Dream: Half-melted orange creamsicles are the very thing that needed to be made into a cookie. Citrus orange blends into creamy vanilla dough, making this flavor a dream come true.
Pricing
All order requests are reviewed and quoted individually. Your price will always pertain to your order! The minimum order for custom cookies is one dozen of any one flavor. These designer cookies start at $45 per dozen, with an average cost of $50-$65 per dozen.
Quotes for custom cakes, tiered cakes, macarons, decorated macarons, cake pops, cupcakes, dessert tables, pies, breads, tarts, or other specialty items will be given following an order request.
If you’re looking to purchase individual cookies or smaller quantities, visit Tastefully Human in-person at a 2023 local farmer’s market! Visit our social media for event and market details.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I order other custom items besides cookies?
Yes! For questions regarding orders of custom cakes, tiered cakes, macarons, decorated macarons, cake pops, cupcakes, dessert tables, pies, breads, tarts, or other specialty items, please visit the contact page.
Can I have my cookies/cake/products delivered?
All delivery is reviewed and offered on a case-by-case basis. If you need special accommodations or have a particular request in regards to delivery of any product, please include it on your order form.
Where is Tastefully Human located?
Tastefully Human is a home bakery that caters to Macomb County, Michigan. Orders are accepted from anywhere within the state of Michigan. Please note: for orders outside of a 25 mile radius, delivery may not be an option.
When will I pay for my order?
Payment is due upon receipt of your ordered products. During seasonal peaks, you may be asked to pay a nominal deposit to reserve your order spot—this will be rolled into your final order cost.
What forms of payment are accepted?
You may pay with credit, debit, cash, check, ApplePay, and GooglePay.
Can I make changes to my order?
Following an order confirmation, you will receive a sketch of the design(s) for your cookies/cake/products, as well as other order details. Upon receipt, there is a 48-hour time frame for making any guaranteed adjustments to the design. (Large order changes will be reviewed and accepted or declined on a case-by-case basis.) After the initial 48 hours, no change requests are guaranteed, but will make every attempt to be accommodated.
How are my cookies packaged?
Your cookies are individually packaged and labeled in heat-sealed clear bags. They are then wrapped and boxed.
How long will my cookies keep?
Your cookies are intended for timely consumption—tasting best at their freshest! But if you’ve eaten one too many, individually packaged cookies (left unopened) will last 3-4 weeks.
If you have questions regarding the storage of custom cakes, tiered cakes, macarons, decorated macarons, cake pops, cupcakes, dessert tables, pies, breads, or tarts, please reach out.
Which cookie flavor is the best?
I knew you’d ask!
It’s a tough pick… There’s nothing quite like classic vanilla almond, but also, how could you pass up pink lemonade? It’s a hard choice, but I’d have to say confetti… actually peach… no, definitely chocolate… ah, I don’t know, just try them all!
